Looks like a huge lose

J

jamous91

Guest
big about of whiptail fry died just hours old :( hope i get ten
 

scatz

Retired Staff
Apr 8, 2009
5,379
2
38
48
Devon, UK
sorry to hear its not going well, there must be something wrong with the water if they are dying so fast, i hope some do make it
 

Bigjohnnofish

Global Moderators
Staff member
Apr 15, 2010
1,399
2
36
Perth, Western Australia
gravel is a much better substrate than a glass bottom as far as fry survival goes..... theres plenty of reasons why, but i dont have the time to go through them all now!.....

fry dying so quick is an indication the water is at a toxic level for them... whether it be nitrates,nitrites,ammonia,copper,heavy metals or some of the chemicals added to your tap water before it gets to you....
if i was a betting man i'd go ammonia......

just be carefull whatever it is - it doesnt get worse and kill ya parents too :dk:
 
J

jamous91

Guest
gravel is a much better substrate than a glass bottom as far as fry survival goes..... theres plenty of reasons why, but i dont have the time to go through them all now!.....

fry dying so quick is an indication the water is at a toxic level for them... whether it be nitrates,nitrites,ammonia,copper,heavy metals or some of the chemicals added to your tap water before it gets to you....
if i was a betting man i'd go ammonia......

just be carefull whatever it is - it doesnt get worse and kill ya parents too :dk:
i am not trying to be rude or make out that your wrong but if everything that you have said is wrong then why did the parents lay there eggs in the first place
 

scatz

Retired Staff
Apr 8, 2009
5,379
2
38
48
Devon, UK
i am not trying to be rude or make out that your wrong but if everything that you have said is wrong then why did the parents lay there eggs in the first place
fry are much more delicate than adults, the water needs to be near to perfect for a good survival rate, the fact that your fry died so soon means that something is wrong with the water.
The matter can worsen quickly, lots of dead fry will add more toxins to the water.
up the water change regime to make sure its as clean as you can keep it

Having fish breed is no indication that the water is good, it just means that you have a pair of mature fish and that the set up is ok for them
 
J

jamous91

Guest
fry are much more delicate than adults, the water needs to be near to perfect for a good survival rate, the fact that your fry died so soon means that something is wrong with the water.
The matter can worsen quickly, lots of dead fry will add more toxins to the water.
up the water change regime to make sure its as clean as you can keep it

Having fish breed is no indication that the water is good, it just means that you have a pair of mature fish and that the set up is ok for them
i think i better start cleaning the bottom tank p.s both my tanks have sand in them i thought it looked good but now it is a pain in the bck side
 

JoePlec

Member
Aug 27, 2010
786
0
16
Rainhill, Merseyside
i think i better start cleaning the bottom tank p.s both my tanks have sand in them i thought it looked good but now it is a pain in the bck side
When doing a water change do you stir your sand up? What filtration is on the tank? When was last water change and what % was changed?
 
J

jamous91

Guest
When doing a water change do you stir your sand up? What filtration is on the tank? When was last water change and what % was changed?
the tank the fry is in is a sponge filter and no i do nnnot
 

JoePlec

Member
Aug 27, 2010
786
0
16
Rainhill, Merseyside
the tank the fry is in is a sponge filter and no i do nnnot
Sounds like you have found your culprit. Sand will hold toxins and if not stirred will mess your water up. And sponge filter is not going to do nothing to help that. The fry never really had a chance mate. Few large water changes and stir the sand as you go. Then stir it every waterchange before you take water out. Put it down to experiance.

How often are water changes on the tank and what percentage do you change.
 
J

jamous91

Guest
Sounds like you have found your culprit. Sand will hold toxins and if not stirred will mess your water up. And sponge filter is not going to do nothing to help that. The fry never really had a chance mate. Few large water changes and stir the sand as you go. Then stir it every waterchange before you take water out. Put it down to experiance.

How often are water changes on the tank and what percentage do you change.
once a week but tank was not used for few week but i think i will change it all out and i have done a new thread so can u take a look
 

Lornek8

Member
Apr 21, 2009
2,001
0
36
Hawaii
Filters lose biological capacity if no fish are present in the tank for an extended period. Have you checked water parameters?
 

Irene0100

UK Support Team
May 14, 2009
4,272
0
36
Norfolk, UK
oh dear, maybe the sand is too deep, how deep is it?
i agree best chance for now is a large water change with water at same temp as tank.
also make sure the water is well oxygenated.
please tell us more, such as tank size, temp, how hard/soft the water is, ph etc
 
J

jamous91

Guest
oh dear, maybe the sand is too deep, how deep is it?
i agree best chance for now is a large water change with water at same temp as tank.
also make sure the water is well oxygenated.
please tell us more, such as tank size, temp, how hard/soft the water is, ph etc
sponge filter
bit more than half a inch of sand bog wood and tube that is 6 inch long
 

JoePlec

Member
Aug 27, 2010
786
0
16
Rainhill, Merseyside
no the adluts were in about 8 days or so thts where they liad the eggs
I dont get why you move fish around all the time.. What you say doesnt really make sense can you run down where the fish were at first then why you moved them then why you moved the fry and back again ? I cant work out your fishkeeping.